Sat 24 Sep 2005
I love the new Yahoo mail. It’s rapidly becoming my primary mail system. Good spam blocking, great user interface, really works on all my computers/browsers. Gmail doesn’t. And the Gmail UI is looking pretty pale compared to Yahoo’s. Now we’re in a sweet spot, possibly a very sweet spot. Two great development companies competing for our attention, and neither of them is Microsoft. Come to think of it, neither is Apple. Yahoo!
Dave Winer says that Microsoft isn’t trying to compete with Google’s Gmail or Yahoo’s new (and awesome) email system. Um, Dave, that’s not true. You might want to watch this video about the new Hotmail that’s under development or this one about the new Outlook Express, now called Windows Mail, that’s also under development.
I have to disagree with Scoble here. The new Microsoft Mail web app that is shown off in that video is quite cool indeed, but notice that the one feature that Dave Winer was talking about in his brief post on the subject was “works anywhere”—which, for all you Microsofties who aren’t Sanaz or Steve or the rest of the awesome Start.com team, does NOT mean everywhere that runs Windows. When Scoble asks the new Mail team about other browsers, they say that “the majority of our [must be Hotmail’s] user base is on IE 5 and 6” (by the way, I love the use of version numbers of the SAME BROWSER to make it sound like they are supporting more configs). When Scoble then asks Scott Isaacs about browser/OS compatibility for these web apps, he says “it works on Firefox.” While not awful, Microsoft needs to get its act together. The WPF/E team showed off their wares on OS X running Safari, which after all is the default browser on the Mac. If Safari is a bit anemic right now, then Microsoft should approach Apple’s team (as I’m sure they’ve done in the past) and try to solve this. You cannot have a web platform (whether it be the MSN one, ATLAS, or WPF/E) if it only runs on Wintel Machines running IE. Firefox is really important and Safari is somewhat important, and this is what Google really understands, and what from what we’re hearing Yahoo is understanding with this new Yahoo Mail. It remains to be seen, but from what I’ve seen I would pick the Microsoft offering over the Yahoo one[who knows what Google is up to], but alas it probably won’t work on my Safari browser. Maybe next time, right Microsoft?